Shoes vs NO shoes?????

All my horses are barefoot the farrier told me not to put shoes on Rodeo cuz his feet are good and tough i ride him on pavement,gravel roads,dirt rocky roads, up really rough hills and he has always been fine. I also owned a arabian and she didnt need shoes either ... If i was you id take to your farrier about if you should put shoes on her or not but it sounds like she doesnt need shoes...